Pre-read context: I write my Start/Sit article by selecting someone outside the consensus top-12 at each position and explaining why I believe they can outperform expectations. Conversely, I also pick a player inside the consensus top-12 and explain why I expect them to underperform. This isn't a typical “must start” or “must sit” style article, so it doesn’t necessarily mean swapping this player for that player. Roster depth and matchup status should drive decision-making here. Let’s dive in.
Wide Receivers
Struggling with a WR Sit/Start decision? Check out our
Sit/Start Tool for FREE
Start: Carnell Tate (TEN) vs. DAL
Death, taxes, and start your wide receivers against the Dallas Cowboys defense. Fellow wide receiver Wan’Dale Robinson is now on the injured reserve as Tate returns from a brief absence due to a shoulder injury. Titans quarterback Cam Ward has had a brief hot streak of fantasy production over the last couple of weeks, and while I have concerns about him as the long-term answer, he’s set up well again against an exploitable Cowboys defense. He’ll need to throw the ball in this one to keep up with the potent Dak-led offense, which is an -8.0 home favorite. In fact, this game is projected to be the highest-scoring affair of the week at a 55.0-point total.
Tate’s usage and efficiency have been exactly what you want to see out of a highly drafted rookie wide receiver. Over his last five games, he’s commanded an alpha-level 27.6% target share. With that target share, he’s above the 2.00 benchmark for yards per route run, at 2.35 over the last five games and 2.03 for the year. Dallas runs Zone defense (68.5%) and Middle Closed (57.8%) shells on most snaps, while leaning on Man coverage (23.4%) at the ninth-highest rate in the NFL. Tate torches Cover 3 defense for 0.50 fantasy points per route run (FP/RTE); however, he struggles more against Man, dropping to 0.33 FP/RTE. If Dallas deploys more Cover 3 defense (which they do at a 35.4% rate), he’ll produce more easily.
Vegas has Tate’s prop bets set at 65.5 receiving yards (-114 O, -114 U), and nine of the last ten receivers hit the over on their reception props. Michael Wilson caught eight, Makai Lemon caught seven, and Matthew Golden caught six. With a favorable game script for passing and dome conditions to play in, there should be plenty of opportunity to eat off manufactured, catch-up targets alone. Tate comes into the week as the expert consensus WR23, but I’d be comfortable starting him ahead of guys ranked ahead of him like Deebo Samuel and DK Metcalf , as his upside could be a surprise WR1 performance this week and the volume floor should be there to at least match these guys, if not beat them outright.
Sit: Chris Olave (NO) vs. CHI
Chris Olave was a massive sell-high candidate for me earlier this season, and I caught some flak for it. He’s a good player, but he’s far from what I would label “elite.” Jordyn Tyson is back and healthy, and has lit the world on fire with his usage after just two games. He's significantly impacted Olave as a target option, and while I think Olave will still be good for fantasy, his upside is clearly limited with Tyson on the field. Remember, when Rasheed Shaheed was on the Saints, he was enough of a target competition to be a thorn in Olave’s side for fantasy production. Tyson is a substantially better talent than Shaheed ever was.
This week, expert consensus has Olave as the WR10, and while he has the talent to finish there, I think he may struggle to finish the week that high. The Saints are taking on the Chicago Bears this week, who have become a much different offense since adding All-Pro defensive tackle Jeffrey Simmons. Over the last three games, the Bears have been a top-12 defensive unit at preventing opposing wide receivers from scoring fantasy points (25.4/game). They have held wide receivers to an average of eight receptions, 122.7 yards, and 0.7 touchdowns over that timeframe.
Saints quarterback Tyler Shough will have his work cut out for him, as he’ll face a Bears pass rush that’s now top-seven in holding opposing offenses to a -0.003 Dropback EPA and top-six at preventing dropback success (42.2%).
Chicago is coming off their bye week, with an extra week to prepare, and Vegas isn’t exactly high on Chris Olave this week. His current player props are set at 68.5 receiving yards ( -114 O, -113 U) and 5.5 receptions (+111 O, -147 U). Six out of nine comparable wide receivers failed to hit the over on their receptions prop this year.
While the Saints are -11.5-point dogs in this matchup, it’s hard to trust Olave as a top-12 option right now, especially with Shough’s recent struggles and the impact Tyson has had on target competition. Weather in this game is forecasted to be relatively mild, with a slight chance of rain and 10mph winds. I’m more comfortable starting Luther Burden , Zay Flowers , and Garret Wilson , all ranked behind him this week by expert consensus, because I don’t think the talent is much different and the target volume is more trustworthy given their matchups.
Running Backs
Struggling with an RB Sit/Start decision? Check out our
Sit/Start Tool for FREE
Start: Jonah Coleman (DEN) vs. LV
It’s Coleman season, baby! With RJ Harvey still on the injured reserve and J.K. Dobbins looking like a shell of himself, I expect the workhorse role to stay with one of my favorite running backs this offseason. He’s currently the expert consensus RB13 for the week, but there’s a strong argument he should be ranked inside the top-12 at the position as the Broncos face the Raiders this week as -10.0-point home favorites.
Over the last three games, Jonah Coleman has seen his snap share climb from 49% to 77% for the last game before their bye week. He finished as a top-12 back in both of the last two games he’s played since taking over this backfield, and I expect that trend to continue against a vulnerable Las Vegas defense.
The Raiders are tied for fifth in allowing the most fantasy points per game to opposing running backs this year (25.4). They’re allowing an average of 131.9 rushing yards and 1 touchdown per game to running backs. Coleman is not only the lead back, but he’s also the best healthy receiving back, which raises his floor: he’s caught four passes in each of the last two games, with a target share of 14.5% over that span.
Nine out of ten running backs have hit the over on their rushing yards line against this defense, and Coleman is currently set at 67.5 yards (-113 O, -132 U). Vegas agrees the receiving floor should be there, as they favor his 3.5-reception prop (-137). He’s also favored to hit on his anytime touchdown prop (-145).
In a game where the Broncos should be in full control, and with no significant weather concerns, I’m more comfortable starting Jonah Coleman over guys currently ranked ahead of him, like Chase Brown and even Bucky Irving.
Sit: Bucky Irving (TB) vs. DET
This one will likely catch some flak, as Bucky has been mostly phenomenal this season, especially compared to expectations coming into the year. However, as I said in the pre-read, I’m selecting a guy inside the top-12 who could struggle this week. Bucky arguably has the toughest matchup, especially if Baker Mayfield is out and Jalon Daniels is back at the helm.
The Detroit defense has been very vulnerable against the pass, but it’s been stout against the run. Losing Aidan Hutchinson for the year is a massive blow, but there’s still solid talent in their front seven. Detroit has been a top-two unit against opposing running backs this year, holding them to just 17.5 fantasy points per game. This comes from limiting running back production to 67.7 rushing yards and 0.4 touchdowns per game. Bucky isn’t a prolific pass catcher, as that’s Kenneth Gainwell’s forte, so his floor is lower in this matchup, and he could be scripted out of the game if the Lions take a big lead early.
As it stands of this writing, Detroit are -6.5 home favorites, as Vegas is still projecting Baker to start. If he doesn’t, I’d expect this line to swing even further in Detroit’s favor. Vegas projections also show pessimism toward Bucky, as his 67.5 rushing-yard prop slightly leans toward the under and his receptions prop is set at a weak 1.5 receptions. They also have his anytime touchdown prop with unfavorable odds (+125). Seven out of the last nine running backs have failed to hit the over on their rushing yards prop against this defense.
If Bucky fails to score a touchdown, it’s very unlikely he finishes as a top-12 running back this week. I’d rather start Jonah Coleman, Breece Hall , and Emmett Johnson , and I would even consider Ollie Gordon over him this week, and they are all currently ranked behind him.
Looking for MORE fantasy football insight? Check out our ARTICLES page
Think Like a GM
Start managing your team on Dynatyze, where our data & tools lead to championships. Sign up today and dominate your league.